Despite knowing what all the Horsemen are capable of, magically or otherwise, he really wasn't expecting that, and so he stares at her for a moment before breaking into a grin. A small sound, equal parts amused and pleased, follows as he sets down his drink.

"First one here," he confirms, reaching for the bottle of wine as he gets to his feet. He glances down at the bottle briefly, to check the color and the kind (that's important as far as what to do with it goes), he continues with, "You know, if you're all planning on coming in though the window, I'm gonna feel kinda cheated."

See also: the puzzle he left downstairs.